Native American language * Native American people index * What's new on our site today!

Bering Strait Theory

Why do American Indians get so mad when you say their ancestors migrated across the Bering land bridge from Asia?

Well, there are several reasons. First of all, that contradicts the religious tradition of many native peoples, which claim we have always been here. Surely you know some white people who claim that the earth can't be thousands of years old because it conflicts with the Bible. It is the same principle--except that the Christian fundamentalists get a lot of attention and even nice mentions in textbooks, whereas the Indians are ignored. That gives them an extra reason to be mad.

However, though there is a wide spectrum of native religions in the Americas, most of them tend to be less hierarchical and more flexible than Christianity. If you asked most Indians in some respectful manner, I think you'd find most of them wouldn't have a problem reconciling a philosophical belief that we have lived here since time immemorial with natural evidence that we arrived here at least 20,000 years ago. Why shouldn't they both be true? The Creator is great, we don't always understand the whole world.

But now the problem is, most of us have not been asked this in a respectful manner. Instead, a lot of people have used this Bering Strait bridge theory to belittle Native Americans as "not really native" (a claim that is stupid as well as insulting, since the same scientific facts they use to show the immigration theory also clearly show we have been here at least 20,000 years--longer than men have inhabited England.) Furthermore, missionaries in the past commonly ignored our religious traditions and oral history as inferior to scientific findings-- while at the same time touting their own religious traditions as superior to science. Is it any wonder that this sort of hypocrisy makes Indians angry?

So, if some native people disagree with my conclusion that the Bering Strait theory is probably true, that's fine with me. I respect the religious beliefs of people who believe their ancestors were here since the beginning of time, and I respect the scientific knowledge of the world that suggests we inhabited our homeland more than 20,000 years ago. What I do NOT respect are:

1) people who insist that we are a lost tribe of Israel who immigrated here, no matter what science says, because their religion says so. If we are using religion as our measuring stick, then our religious traditions about where we came from matter much more than someone else's. Use your religion to tell your own story and leave us out of it.

2) people who insist that we have been here only 700, 1000, or 2000 years. If we are using science as our measuring stick, then all the scientific evidence is that the Americas have been inhabited for at least 20,000 years. There are even ruins which are known to be 12,000 years old. To use science to prove we are immigrants here and then ignore how long science says we have been here is hypocritical.

If you don't fall in either of those categories, then your respectful decision to believe in the Bering Strait migration theory or not is of no consequence to me. As long as we are all agreed that Indians have lived on these lands for at least 20,000 years, about twice as long as anyone has lived in England, then I don't think we have anything to quarrel about.

Orrin.

Books on the Bering Strait theory:

The Bering Land Bridge: Here's the full case for the Bering Strait theory by the scientist who brought it to popularity.
Red Earth, White Lies: Lakota author Vine Deloria Jr.'s book criticizing the Bering Strait land bridge theory
and its proponents from an indigenous perspective.
Bones, Boats, and Bison: Scholarly text by archaeologist E. James Dixon rejecting the Bering bridge theory
in favor of coastal migrations from Asia.

Websites on the Bering Strait theory:

Bering Straits Theory: Concise explanation of what the Bering land bridge theory suggests.
Theories about the Bering Strait: Discussion of the Bering land bridge and other theories about American Indian origins.
First Nations Migration Theories: Discussion of the Bering land bridge and other theories about American Indian origins.
Paleo-American Origins: Discussion of the Bering land bridge and other theories about American Indian origins.
Ancient Bones May Rewrite Theory: Article on sea-route alternatives to the Bering Straight theory.
Rewriting American Prehistory: Article discussing archaeological finds that predate the "ice-free corridor."
Journeys of Our Native Tongues: Linguist Johanna Nichols' analysis of Amerindian language families suggests
American Indians have inhabited the Americas for at least 35,000 years.
Did First Americans Arrive By Land and Sea?: Article disputing the single-migration theory.
Discovery Casts Doubts On Bering Land Bridge Theory: Synopsis of a Science article reassessing Siberian migration theories.



Back to Orrin's homepage
Back to Setting The Record Straight
Language of the day: Tsalagi

Native Languages

Native American Indian tribes * Native American art * Native names * Native poetry * Tribal tattoos

Would you like to help support our organization's work with endangered American Indian languages?

or buy some books through this link:

Native Languages of the Americas website 1998-2011 * Contacts and FAQ page